Unlock Secret Menus Without Saying the Wrong Thing
Secret menus aren’t really secrets—they’re just off-menu items that insiders and frequent customers know how to order. But the trick isn’t just what to ask for. It’s how to ask. Whether you’re trying to get Animal Style fries at In-N-Out or a hidden drink from Starbucks, here’s how to unlock fast food’s best-kept secrets without getting side-eyed by the staff.
Know What You Want—And How to Explain It
Employees aren’t trained on secret menus, so don’t walk up to the counter and casually say, “I’ll take the White Gummi.” Instead, describe the build of the item you want. Be respectful, clear, and ready to explain exactly how to customize your order.
For example:
- At McDonald’s, the McGangBang = one McChicken sandwiched inside a double cheeseburger. Order both items and build it yourself.
- At Starbucks, the Pink Drink with matcha cold foam isn’t on the menu. Ask for a Pink Drink and request matcha cold foam on top.
Start With These Secret Menu Favorites
Want to ease into the world of secret menus? These items are popular, easy to explain, and often happily made by employees:
- In-N-Out Animal Style Everything
Fries, burgers, grilled cheese—ask for them “Animal Style” for added cheese, grilled onions, and secret sauce. No explanation usually needed. - Starbucks Medicine Ball
This immune-boosting tea combo became so popular, it’s now called the Honey Citrus Mint Tea. But if the barista looks confused, just ask for half hot water, half steamed lemonade, one Jade Citrus Mint tea bag, one Peach Tranquility tea bag, honey, and optional peppermint. - Chipotle Quesarito
A burrito wrapped in a cheese quesadilla. Some locations only allow it for mobile orders. Ask politely, and if it’s a no-go, order both separately and build your own. - Shake Shack Peanut Butter & Bacon Burger
This used to be a real menu item. Now you’ll need to ask for a ShackBurger and add peanut butter sauce and bacon—if the store has both available.
Use Tools Like Hack the Menu
Sites like Hack the Menu are goldmines for discovering secret and discontinued items from fast food chains across the country. They often include specific ordering instructions to help you avoid confusion at the register.
Timing and Tone Matter
Want to increase your chances of success? Avoid peak lunch and dinner hours. Employees are more likely to honor special requests when the kitchen isn’t slammed. Also, use a friendly tone—remember, you’re asking for a favor outside the norm.
Final Tip: Order Digitally for More Control
Some apps like Starbucks and Taco Bell offer far more customization options in their mobile ordering systems than you’ll get in person. If you’re shy about special requests or want to avoid miscommunication, apps are your best friend.
